Recruit 2-3 students to come upfront to the leader who has a toaster plugged in. Set the toaster on the lowest setting. Place one slice of bread in the toaster and set to toast. Steadily read a list of spread consequences repeating until the toast pops. Whatever spread is said the student gets their toast and spread to eat.
Here’sa list of possible spreads but you can think of more. I threw in some desired ones for fun as well.
Vienna Sausage Juice