I know I’m jumping the gun but Christmas flat out rocks! With would you rather scenarios you can divide the large group into smaller groups of 3-4 and have them respond with the answer and why or you can have the entire group stand in the middle and move to the sides of the room that you dictate for the answer. Example: If you would rather  ”this” go to this side of the room  and if you would rather “that” go to the other side.

1. Would you rather have gotten for Christmas when you were a kid every single lego set known to man or every single pokemon?

2. Would you rather give or receive?

3. Would you rather see on Christmas day every one’s debt completely erased or no one to ever go hungry again?

4. Would you rather be Frosty the Snowman or Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer?

5. Would you rather have Christmas in Tokyo or in London?

6. Would you rather see snow on Christmas or the beach?

7. Would you rather ride in a one horse sleigh or a bobsled?

8. Would you rather open your presents up on Christmas morning at Disney World or in Hawaii?

9. Would you rather want on Christmas day to see no more disease or no more poverty?

10. Would you rather have apple pie or cherry pie on Christmas?

11. Would you rather be a wise man or a shepherd?

If you have any other scenarios please share them in the comment field below. Enjoy.

Image adapted from Creative Commons
Advertise for your blog, resource, or site on the Stash.



  1. Richard Jones December 3, 2010 at 3:00 pm #

    Would you rather know what your gifts are or be surprised?

    Would you rather go caroling or put up decorations?

    Would you rather eat fruitcake or sit on Santa’s lap in front of people you know?

    Would you rather be Mary or Elizabeth?

    Would you rather have your Christmas cookies with sprinkles or without?

    Would you rather give someone something they really need or something they really want?

  2. chadswanzy December 3, 2010 at 3:09 pm #

    those are sooo good!

  3. chad swanzy December 3, 2010 at 7:20 pm #

    Richard I made another set of would you rather christmas scenarios under the mixer tab at the top of the page. They include all 6 of your questions thanks again for the input!

  4. Adam Lehman December 5, 2010 at 12:41 pm #

    Using these tonight!

  5. Paul Wu December 17, 2010 at 9:51 am #

    This is awesome. I’m doing this as a ice breaker with a joint Christmas winterfest we’re having a with a church in East Austin during dinner.

  6. marck December 21, 2012 at 12:05 pm #

    Would u rather have to feel the duty of santa claus or be his wife

  7. christy December 11, 2013 at 12:56 pm #

    would you rather:
    Drink egg nog or peppermint tea?
    Take the month of December off of school or the month of September
    Get a free “pass” on a test at school or not have to turn in a homework assignment?
    Carol a nursing home or shovel a shut-in’s driveway?
    Watch Christmas specials with the family or drive around looking at Christmas lights with them?

    (we do this type of game as an Experiential Educational ice-breaker to help others see who they might connect with and gives the leader an idea of personal insights into each student. We also, will sometimes do this in a small group setting and take the “opposite choice” and try to see the “benefit” in it. Helps each student ‘walk in the other persons shoes” for a brief moment.


  1. Would You Rather? Tag | Tried and Tested Blog - January 27, 2014

    […] Image Source: http://youthleaderstash.com/2010/11/23/would-you-rather-christmas-scenarios/ […]

Leave a Reply